How large and well trained are YOU? JK Here's my take on this.  Do you have any experience? If so what did you like about that boat? What did you dislike? If not and you're new to the game, RENT! Untill you find one you like. Test drive all boats loaded! All newer model canoes have good points and bad, there's trade offs from speed to stability and vice versa. I've never paddled a boat that was to light, I have paddled a tank and I'll never forget it.  ;)The perfect boat for me might not trip as well for you. I liked a Bell Northwoods, but I sold her and bought 2 solos, I like them ALOT better!! Don,t discount 2 solos,my wife loves hers. Noah liked his Ark. You might like something in between!  ;)