i guess i should mention a few points of interest. when considering trolling lures i pretty much aim for what i think the trout will like most and let the rest fall into place. i dont think trolling up in the Q is the best way to pick up walleyes. i view it as a trout first, because you are paddling and there is a rod and a holder and a lure so why not second sort of option. i know not everyone is of the same mindset, but let me continue. i wonder what lures have caught the most trout over the years. flies, spoons, and inline mepps spinners would be my first guesses(when it comes to artificials). flies are silent completely sight based lures. spoons are big and flashy but on the silent side. and mepps are quiet but provide turbulence for the lateral line. and here we chat about rattles. i must think on this further!