I felt the same way about the Chota Q Trekkers.  A different footbed helps.  I put in Superfeet insoles and it made a world of difference.  They are tough, waterproof and take a lot of abuse. 

Another boot that a fried tried out this year have good promise.  They are made by Sorel - the Woodbine Surplus.  Heavy canvas, grippy soles, lace up - no drain ports, but the canvas let the water out quite nicely.  You could always add your own gromets.  They were on sale at the local Columbia outlet store, so I bought three pair at only $30 each, down from $100. 

pd