Pikeman,

Thaniks for the insights. I just recently acquired a spring creek clamp in seat because my snap always seemed to be dangling at the end of my bungy cord during portages. Doh!

I'm going to be evaluating this new one for weight, ease-of-installation and positioning in our Wenonah Champlain this season. My only concern at the moment is whether the occupant will be sitting too high and thus change the center of gravity (making us a bit more 'top heavy") when we travel.

On the other hand, I have really liked the snap-in seat and can't make up my mind whether to part with it. Can always keep the two and sell the one I don't want I guess! Thanks again for the info -- I considered getting the style you had but ran into a large group of scouts and leaders on bwca 1-week trip who ddin't report back on it favorably ---- always good to hear what you and others think on these various options!