Mad Mat,

I'm a big fan of Sno-Seal as well but while looking for info about Neatfoot oil, I saw an article that said Sno-Seal was a good choice but had some drawbacks compared to thinner boot oil. :-/

I never had a problem with it, but then again my Dad and his buddies never did with Neatfoot oil.

I think one thing that's important is that you clean/dry your boots before applying any waterproof/leather conditioner.

Like paint, the prep is the key.