I wear a mustang survival automatic inflatable PFD. I have never seen an inflatable on another paddler. I like it because I always wear it and never know I have it on. I am curious as to why it's not more popular and accepted on still waters? Am I missing something? 

I intentionally bought a conventional PFD that had large front pockets for survival and fishing gear.  It also provides a handy padded seat for lunch stops (and at other times).

Also I tend to do some of my travel in the shoulder seasons (May/September) when the extra insulation (warmth) is desirable.

dd

I wonder if there is ever a scenario when one would not be able to pull the cord or press the button with Sally?

like the other have said, I find a standard PFD to be a multi-use item

often wear it for the extra insulation, keep my map handy in the pocket, use if for my pillow

also, they are reasonably cheap - the one I use in Quetico is a cheapo from Cabelas, and its the lightest PFD I have, so its the one that goes.

since I don't have any problem wearing it, I don't see that an inflateable really offers any advantages for me - so I've never given an inflateable a thought.

and, a regular PFD is fool-proof as long as its on - there is always chance an inflateable will malfunction - maybe even leak air ? and maybe you will catch the ripcord on a pack and have it inflate by accident ?


edit:  I took a look at the Mustang PFDs - couldn't find any weights given, but they don't look to be all that much lighter than my regualr PFD.  Not all the Mustang models had USCG Type III - ratings   - in Colorado, by law, you have to have a USCG Type III for each person in the canoe - so that could be a consideration for anyone buying one (Type II or seat cushion type is not an acceptable alternative- and yes, I've been checked several times)

I looked at the Stearns models a bit also- some said Type V approved for use as Tpe III (and some not) - depending on what the label actually says, these might not "fle" with some of the boating rangers.

its been some time since I've actually read the rules here, but it would be something to check on if I was thinking of getting an inflateable

Mad Mat's question as to the legality of an inflatable in the park is quite relevant and had never crossed my mind. I assumed that since U S coast guard wears them and offshore sailors use them it would not be an issue. I have sent an inquiry to the park and will post the results when I get an answer. Mat, if you have saved me eventual grief how do you like your steak? ( or pasta prima vera if your one of those veggie types)