Lots of good points in this thread. I much prefer a 1 piece rod and would forego a rod case although I like what OS has going on. Just the right amount of protection plus ease and availability. Only the front end of your rod needs protection IMO on a canoe trip. 2 piece rods invariably suggest a rod case lest you run the risk of losing a piece.

But down to brass tacks on the baitcaster decision. I enjoy using a baitcaster as much as I enjoy a spinning reel and typically have both with me. Light line and lighter lures go with the spinner (4/6/8/10 lb test) and the baitcaster handles 12 to 20 lb test very nicely. I would think in terms of line classes when deciding what outfit to bring. If you only feel comfortable throwing cranks on 12 lb test with a baitcaster without snarling things up I would weigh very carefully wether that would be my strategy as cranks for the most part do better with lighter line. Plus throwing lures in the backyard on a nice calm day is quite different than with the wind in your face. Get my drift?