Fallguy,
I can’t answer for the 5 gal bucket system as yet but using either the 2-Rubbermaid clear bins or the 3-15 qt clear bins, they both carry equally as well because I pack them like you would a conventional backpack.
By that I mean you load the weight so the heaviest load is closest to your lower back/hip belt.
The 5 gal buckets present a little different challenge to load because they’re round, but I’ll work that out as I go.
The reason I wanted 2-5 gal buckets or the 2 combinations of rectangular Rubbermaid boxes is I use the containers for more than just hauling food.
I like to sit and relax around camp after a long day so I want to sit in comfort and still be able to cook without kneeling on the ground.
I bought this camp chair so I could sit under my Dri-fly and cook/relax and even set up/break down my tent without getting wet OR even standing up if I don’t feel like it.
(You need to Login or Register to view media files and links)With the clear container or now the 5 gal bucket, I will use the top of them for a place to set my Peak 1 Stove and as prep table or just a place to set a evening drink on around the fire. I set my stove in a cheap aluminum disposal pie pan so no food spills on food box.
(You need to Login or Register to view media files and links)IMHO the biggest advantage of having more than 1 food container is you can divide your food by meals/type and you don’t end up digging thru a big single barrel to find the items you want to eat. Even if you pack in different colored sacks, the bouncing around on portages is going to have things shifting and settling around.
I pack my suppers/adult beverage which tend to be the heaviest in the bottom box/bucket and the top one is the breakfast/lunch items and drink mixes.
When I went to the 3-15 qt boxes, I did the same but made one box all snacks/drink mixes.
The buckets will be packed the same-way so the same type items are packed together and easy to identify and get too.
When I’m on the water/portage and want to have lunch/snack, I just open pack, remove the lid and it’s all right there.
This system was conceived to fit my style as a solo paddler and might not be for everyone. IF you’re happy with what you do now, then you should stick with it, BUT if you’re not then it’s worth a look see.
Also remember I had a Food pack already and needed a packing system I could adapt and keep my pack. I’m glad I had the pack first, because I had looked at those blue barrels, but for the reasons I mentioned before I didn't think it would fit my style of tripping.
I also use the pack’s shape to wrap a ¾ Thermarest sleeping pad around the clear boxes/buckets. This has multiple advantages or at least I think it does.
I’m hard on my packs. When I’m offloading on rocky landings, I toss them up, roll them up whatever it takes to keep ME safe. So to protect the plastic from breaking hitting a sharp rock I have a 2” piece of close-cell foam on the bottom of my food pack. Then the Thermarest pad wrapped around the containers.
The padding protects and silences the pack as well as provides a layer of insulation on hot days which is nice IF your hauling perishable/heat sensitive food items. It also guarantees that if I dump the food pack will float in any conditions.
Finally, at night I take that pad and lay under my Thermarest foam air mattress for an extra layer of padding and insulation.