db wrote on Sep 2
nd, 2020 at 7:20pm:
All I remember for sure is Keats to McDougall was a serious uphill climb. The guy carrying the canoe on that trip wanted to go back to our camp on Keats via Chatterton because of the downhill risk involved.
His preference made perfect sense to me. Falling uphill has always seemed way preferable to falling downhill, to me at least. Plus it was his canoe so I wasn't going to argue.
A few years back I was over on Keats on a day trip from my camp on McDougall. My paddling partner suggested we eyeball that portage as a "shortcut" back to camp. One glimpse at it was enough for me to "wave the white flag", even though all we had with us was the empty Kevlar canoe & a little fishing gear.
Maybe I would have tackled it as a "challenge" in my youth. Maybe. We did crazy stuff like that back then, pre-double-level back fusion, pre-full hip replacement. I'm thinking doing the Keats-to-McDougall portage would have brought those surgeries on a few years earlier. Unnecessarily, too, considering the alternative route back includes the Chatterton-to-McDougall portage, one of the easiest in the entire park (though Three Mile Lake-to-Wolsely is probably even easier).
By my reckoning, Keats-to-McDougall appeared to be one of Quetico's classic "billy goat" trails. I'd put Poohbah-to-Wink in that category, too, along with half-a-dozen others of that ilk that we tackled in our bygone years.
Thanks, but I'll pass on those, going forward....
Kudos to DD... but me-thinks HE may have left a few too many pieces of HIS mind out in the park, too.
Jimbo